Napoleon and the Failure to Choose
I realized something was wrong about halfway through Napoleon , and it wasn’t a detail I could point to on screen. It was quieter than that. The film was still loud, still busy, still impressively staged, but I had stopped leaning forward. I wasn’t confused by the plot so much as detached from it, as if the movie and I were watching each other from opposite sides of the room, neither quite sure what the other wanted. That feeling never left. This is not a complaint about historical accuracy . That argument misses the point and always has. History on film is interpretation, compression, and emphasis. The question is never whether a film gets every detail right. The question is whether it knows what it is trying to say. This one does not. Is it a love story ? A biopic? A psychological portrait ? A condemnation of war and imperial ambition ? The film gestures toward all of these possibilities, sometimes within the same sequence, then backs away before committing. What remains is not...