When the System Becomes the Case; John Lescroart's Hard Evidence
We do not talk about the justice system the way we talk about other failing systems. We talk about education as strained, healthcare as fragmented, and infrastructure as aging. Justice, by contrast, is still spoken of as if it were intact but misunderstood, principled but misapplied. The language stays reverent even as trust erodes. We ask whether outcomes were fair, rarely whether the structure itself is designed to prefer certain outcomes over others. That is the environment in which Hard Evidence now lives, even if it was written decades earlier. When John Lescroart published the book, the courtroom thriller was already a familiar form, confident, procedural, reassuring in its insistence that truth would surface if the rules were followed closely enough. What Lescroart quietly questioned was not whether the rules worked, but what they worked for. I gave the book four stars because it resists the reader’s desire for comfort. It opens with the signals of a spe...